Luciana VanDette / Juliet
Clint Howard / Smokey
Bradley Stryker / Eddie
Daniel Roebuck / Santa
Daniel Roebuck / Charlie
Chris Jericho / Burke
Tom Savini / Bystander
Jason Patric / Michael
Alex Ross / Mark
Kailey Hyman / Brooke
Kellen Raffaelo / Timmy
Lisa Marie Falcone / Dispatch
Stephen Cofield Jr. / Officer Evans
Corrine Kelly / Bag Lady
Joe Falcone / Dean (as Joseph Falcone)
Peter Mitchell / Cosplayer
Marie Maser / Receptionist
Jon Abrahams / Dennis
Michael Genet / Jackson
Luciana Elisa Quinonez / Young Sienna
Michel Vidal / Armor Clad Demon
Juliana Lamia / The Virgin Mary
Sienna Hubert-Ross / Stacy Bar Girl 1
Charlotte McKee / Sarah Bar Girl 2
Chip Carriere / Dept Store Santa
Andrew Hollinger / Elf
Robert Catalano / Photographer
Lauren Sowa / Mother
Banks Quinney / Little Boy #1
Evelyn Lee / Little Girl #2
Israel Acevedo / Security Guard
Samantha Schwartz / Little Mall Girl
Nariyah Simpson / Carol Anne
Jennifer C. Johnson / Angry Parent
Katie Curri / Angry Parent #2
Preston Christopher Lawrence / Angry Parent #3
Tom White / Angry Parent #4
Ryan Usui / Little Boy #2
Annie Lederman / Graven Image Co-Host
Ilia Krisulas / Rowdy Beta #1
Michael Loverde / Rowdy Beta #2
Dominick Muschello / Rowdy Beta #3
Beethovan Oden / News Anchor
John Sanders / Demon Voice
Phil Falcone / Tom the Bus Driver
Jen Ayer Drake / Woman on Bus
Corinne Kelly / Bag Lady
Peter Gray Lewis / Professor Keller (uncredited)
Christian Stavrakis / Mall Witness (uncredited)