Connie Shi / Bella Franz
Kenney Myers / Karl Block
Laren England / Grocery Girl
Al Sapienza / Artie Stein
John D. O'Loughlin / Firefighter
Tara Westwood / Karen Block
Robert Peterpaul / Maitre-D
Ashley Brooke Miller / Coat Check Girl
Joseph Bessette / Jeff Ackerman
Deborah Rennard / Elaine Stein
Allison Mullaney / Shira Stein
Jojo Kurak / Mrs. Franz
George Zouvelos / Mr. Franz
George Kyriakopoulos / Brian Franz
Brianna Long / Lauren Franz
Wesley Long / Baby Franz
Tyler Rund / Kevin Franz
Jordan Rund / Jessica Franz
Leer Leary / Uncle Jack
Bettina Skye / Aunt Marie
Nicholas Corleto / Jack Jr.
Kelley VanGilder / Aunt Jean
Bart DeFinna / Uncle Scott
Celeste Spataro / Emma
Jaiden Riley / Clint
Alexa Sapienza / Elisabeth
Ariana Franz / Music Teacher
Vincenzo Tambasco-Cerbone / Pianist
Edward Franz / Guitarist
Amy Chiovaro / Chamber of Commerce Member
Donna Drake / Chamber of Commerce Member
Angel Febus / Chamber of Commerce Member
Susan Feinblatt / Chamber of Commerce Member
Alan Fogelman / Chamber of Commerce Member
Meredith Johnson / Chamber of Commerce Member
Monika Mannix / Chamber of Commerce Member
Paul Mannix / Chamber of Commerce Member
Shirley McKay / Chamber of Commerce Member
Lexie San Paolo / Chamber of Commerce Member
Cathie Theofanis / Chamber of Commerce Member
Carmella Kaiser / Pedestrian

Esteban Benito / Seb
Brittany Garms / Dakota
Danny Trejo / Angel
Connie Shi / Greta
Steve Little / Craig
Ithamar Enriquez / Hector
Alain Mora / Rigo
Karen Maruyama / Grandma
Rekha Sharma / Aunt Fern
Rock Kohli / Uncle Ron
Max Malas / Orphan Sammy
Quinn Beswick / Terrified Worker
Adam Herschman / Security Guard Larry
Robert Kelly / Fake Santa
Kiel Kennedy / Officer Gary
Tamika Simpkins / Officer Kaya
Paul Scheer / Soup Anderson
Annie Cavalero / Front Desk Dispatcher
Brenna Sherman / Denise
Jordan VanDina / Worker at Winter Wonderland Gala
Casey Frey / Clyde
Anthony Raimondi / Angry Driver
Spencer Wider / Crowd Member Spencer
Jordan Paris / Neighborhood Kid
Haley Grogan / Paula
Josh Robert Thompson / The Voice of Christmas
Adara Alston / Caroler
Axelle Azoulay / On-air Binger
Michael Callahan / Gala Attendee /  Binger
Nolan Callahan / Binger
Jonathan Campano / Penguin
Chuck Dorgan / Binger
Candace Harewood / Parent at event
Patrick Klein / Santa Clause Binger
Robert J. Korzuch II / Extra
Matti Leetmaa / Binge Launch Party Attendee
Timothy Mundstock / Holiday Binger
Ashlyn Gabel / Gala Child (uncredited)
Emelia Camille Harewood / Child (uncredited)
Raymond G. Wills / On-Air Binger /  Thong Binger (uncredited)