Fran Pulford / Grandma
Giovanni Chechitelli / Neighbor Kid 1
Elijah Chechitelli / Neighbor Kid 2
Rachel Anderson / Becky Manfredo
Shba Cochrane / Mail Carrier
Derek Steyer / Todd Kapoppy
Branislav R. Tatalovic / Mayor McHenry
Evette Smith-Parker / Neighbor Lady
David Solomon Abrams / Deputy Spisak
Bunnie Ferro / Ingrid
Lex Godoy / Guy Sanders
Marsel Hajdari / Deputy Gritz
Scot Teller / Deputy Stony
Jon Huff / Deputy Stubbs
Jason Klingensmith / Deputy Wilson
Jeff Grant / Deputy Figinski
John Tkach / Deputy Tuccolo
Eric Wilhelm / Weatherman Stan
Jess Byard / Arcade Extra 1
Joe Morales / Mynie Moe
Chloe Klotz / Eenie Meanie
Jonny Smail / Smail (animated sequence) /  Arcade Game Player 1 (Extra)
Dallas Bigley / Arcade Patron (Extra)
Evette Parker / Neighbor Lady
Ed Frame / Pastor
Paul Gustovich / Creepy Pharmacist
Kodie Ferro / Fast Food Worker (Extra)
DeJeanu Adams / Elf 2
Nick Adduci / Choir Member (Extra)
Blanco Aleguar / Sportscaster Chip
Jimmy Barber Sr. / Choir Member (Extra)
Kim Carney / Choir Member (Extra)
Marissa Cashbaugh / Choir Member (Extra)
John Catheline / Church Member
Liano Chechitelli / Crying Baby 2
Ellen W. Conrad / Christmas Caroler
Diablo / The Iguana
Cindy Castro DiRusso / Church Member (Extra)
Jeff A. Engalder / Church Member (Extra)
Louie B. Free / Wacky Neighbor
Issy Greathouse / Elf 1
Sarah Gustwiller / Christmas Caroler
Kelly Jackson / Upset Mother 2
Brandy Johanntges / Talk Radio Woman
Ashley Lynn Johnson / Church Member (Extra)
Greg Kraus / Bowler (Extra)
Daniel Lamont / Church Member (Extra)
Courtney Lundgren / Church Member (Extra)
Kenneth L. Martin / Christmas Caroler
Paul Martin / Daddy Spisak
Shayna McConahay / Choir Member (Extra)
Jonathan Metz / Bubble Blower
Chip Miklas / Mall Patron (Extra)
Olivia Miklas / Crying Baby 1
Monica Miles / Young Grandma
Austin Miller / Teen on Phone
Jada Miller / Church Member (Extra)
Charles J. Muszik Jr. / Church Member (Extra)
Mike Newman / Christmas Caroler
Bradley Noble / Young Grandpa
Sean Pakos / Church Member (Extra)
Rayna Perdue / Dream Girl
Danielle Putnam / Church Member (Extra)
Ryan M. Simpson / Church Member (Extra)
Ed Springfield / Sportscaster Rick
Chrystal Star / Choir Member (Extra)
Stephanie Stearns / Choir Member (Extra)
Lexi Sudac / Teen with Attitude
Lindsay Tuttle / Upset Mother 1
Joseph Vaglica / Mall Manager
Angeliyah Webster / Choir Member (Extra)
Heidi Wlodarski / Choir Member (Extra)
Paul Worley / Church Member (Extra)