MacKenzie Graves (Sarah Drew) wants to keep her father's memory alive by continuing his Reindeer Games charity event in her Vermont hometown. But she finds herself getting competitive for folks' attention when Hollywood star Chase Weston (Justin Bruening) arrives. It also doesn't help that he was MacKenzie's high school crush and it so happens that Chase now wants to steal her heart.
Melanie's 17-year-old autistic daughter Jenny is a senior in high school and looking forward to college. After a bad experience her junior year, Jenny is not interested in attending her final Christmas dance before graduating. Melanie decides to surprise Jenny by getting involved in the school's planning committee to create a welcoming dance for all students. Meanwhile, Jenny and her friends secretly plan their own party, in part to honor Melanie. Melanie works with Jenny's literature teacher on the dance and starts to fall for him while Jenny develops something special with a new classmate at school. When their secrets snowball, however, their plans begin to drive a wedge between the usually tightknit mother and daughter at the holidays.
