Ashanti / Self
Kiara Barnes / Self
Jaeden Bettencourt / Self
Rodney Bingenheimer / Self
Ian Buchanan / Self
Kimberly Caldwell / Self
Maylah Chanel / Youth Red Carpet Reporter
Scarlet Checkers / Self (Sword Swallower)
Charity Daw / Self
Derek Dinniene / Self
Jason Dohring / Self
Josh Edmondson / Self
Esteban Steven Escobar / Self - Editor & Camera
Carla Ferrigno / Self
Lou Ferrigno / Self
Rosanna Jean Foss / Self
Arrington Foster / Self
Mikalah Gordon / Self
Aaron Groben / Capt. Tom Bristol
Deidre Hall / Self
Zachary Haven / Self
Jahzrel Henderson / Self (Bonebreaker)
Ernie Hudson / Self
Alice Hunter / Self
Kelley Johnson / Self
Tonya Kay / Segment Host
Lauren Koslow / Self
Blake Lewis / Self
Kate Linder / Self
Omarosa Manigault Newman / Self
Kim Manning / Self (Roller Skater)
Amber Martinez / Self
Jerry Mathers / Self
Maggi Mayfield / Self
Kaitlyn McCormick / Self - Spokesperson for Masha and the Bear
Alexander McDaniel / Self
Karla Mosley / Self
Annika Noelle / Self
Miguel A. Núñez Jr. / Self
Nancy O'Dell / Self
Thaao Penghlis / Self
Krystal Pohaku / Self (Sword Swallower)
Stefanie Powers / Self
Chad Ridgely / Self
Rodney Allen Rippy / Self
Benji Risley / Self
Tristan Rogers / Self
Jessica Ross / Self
Kj Smith / Self
Rowan Smyth / Self
Ruben Studdard / Self
Jordi Vilasuso / Self
Brianni Walker / Reporter
Mark Wallengren / Self
Burt Ward / Self
Elliott Yamin / Self
Jacklyn Zeman / Self

Isabella Rossellini / Liz
Susan Malick / Rachel
Rachel Siegel / Autograph Seeker
Katie Kreisler / Helen
Philip Tabor / Paul
Jordi Vilasuso / Benjamin's Ex
Nat DeWolf / Benjamin's Ex
Joel de la Fuente / Benjamin's Ex
Melanie R. Orr / Scorned Woman
Denis O'Hare / Andrew
Rufus Wainwright / Jeremy
Eric Bogosian / Henry
George Segal / Rabbi Mendel
Angel Desai / Laura
Jonathan Walker / Michael
Regina Schneider / Amanda
Michael Murphy / Jesse
Jane Nichols / Guest 1
Andrew Howard / Ian
Don Fitzgerald / Built Guy
Meghan Glennon / Party Girl
Winsome Brown / SNL Writer
Michael Goldstrom / SNL Writer
Jim Parsons / Oliver
Steve Glenn / Guest 2
Alice Tan Ridley / Subway Singer
Caroline Clay / Subway Woman
Cindy Adams / Self
Alexander Lange / Guest 3
Manny Siverio / Subway Mugger
Frank Shattuck / EMT Worker
D'Vorah Bailey / Police Officer
Jan Ellis / Hospital Receptionist
Liza Colón-Zayas / Ana
Aylam Orian / Juilliard actor
Becca Anderson / Acting Student
James Babbin / Lawyer
Tomm Bauer / Acting Student
Khan Baykal / Max
Brendan Bradley / Student
Daniel Carnevale / Acting Student
Aaron Fiore / Stage Crewman
Brian Hyman / Groom
Sam Masotto / Student
Caroline Memnon / Guest
Ashley Palmer / Acting Student
Andrea Bertola Shaw / Acting Student
Jason Stogsdill / Student
Lorli Villanueva / Diana's Housekeeper